Forum:

Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Confused

  1. #1
    Junior Member Array
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    1

    Default Confused

    Become a member to remove this ad.
    I have been marred for 5 months and last night my husband and I got into a big fight - this has been brewing for some time, we have been rocky for a few months, we make up, it goes well for a couple of days and then we go back again to being distant. We make love once every so and so (when we are not angry with each other). The relationship is so unbalanced. He doesnt have alot of family and he loves my big family, last night when I wanted to leave he wouldn't let me, he kept saying that you can't take my family away from me....you can't leave me, he got so angry that he pushed me to the floor, shaking me and then he put his hands around my neck....he didn't hurt me so much, except for being a little sore today from falling on the floor but what do i do know - he left after he did that and apologised and cried like a baby and feels really bad. He said that he would go to counsellling with me if thats what i want.... taking my family away from him will kill him i know this, im just scared that this will happen again.....

    What do i do....

  2. #2
    TEAM ADMIN Array CHANDLERS WISH's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    19,973
    Blog Entries
    13

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by JHarvie View Post
    I have been marred for 5 months and last night my husband and I got into a big fight - this has been brewing for some time, we have been rocky for a few months, we make up, it goes well for a couple of days and then we go back again to being distant. We make love once every so and so (when we are not angry with each other). The relationship is so unbalanced. He doesnt have alot of family and he loves my big family, last night when I wanted to leave he wouldn't let me, he kept saying that you can't take my family away from me....you can't leave me, he got so angry that he pushed me to the floor, shaking me and then he put his hands around my neck....he didn't hurt me so much, except for being a little sore today from falling on the floor but what do i do know - he left after he did that and apologised and cried like a baby and feels really bad. He said that he would go to counsellling with me if thats what i want.... taking my family away from him will kill him i know this, im just scared that this will happen again.....

    What do i do....
    It sounds like you both got married for all the wrong reasons, as you have only been married 5 months, out of which has been rocky for "a few" months and sexually once every so and so........

    It also sounds like he needs the marriage for the want of the love of your family.

    He does need councelling absolutely, anger management to start with, in my opinion and this is scary, as i don't know but once a person starts this behaviour then a pattern amerges, this is from my experience not from a Physcologists viewpoint obviously.

    He probably is frighten you will leave the tears can be for many reasons.

    Personally, the marriage was over before it began and you don't appear to be to happy and perhaps scared as well.

    I would move out anyway and stay with your family whilst he seeks help and take it from there, if you genuinely feel that there is hope and promise for future.

    But, i tend to think there is none and what if a child was bought into this relationship?

    CW
    Do we not realise that in order to find a soul
    It doesn't happen over night
    if truth were to be told.

    Like everything in life that's hard to achieve
    you must believe!

  3. #3
    March 2008 "Poster of the Month" Array
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    2,805

    Default

    Physical violence is a really bad sign. I think you should get out now while you can. Someone who resorts to physical violence when upset may do so again.

    If you decide to stay, please, do not have a child with this man for at least a couple of years to see how things work out. I say this because he may decide that getting you pregnant is a way to prevent you from leaving.

  4. #4
    VIP Member Array just4me's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    TN
    Posts
    70

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by JHarvie View Post
    I have been marred for 5 months and last night my husband and I got into a big fight - this has been brewing for some time, we have been rocky for a few months, we make up, it goes well for a couple of days and then we go back again to being distant. We make love once every so and so (when we are not angry with each other). The relationship is so unbalanced. He doesnt have alot of family and he loves my big family, last night when I wanted to leave he wouldn't let me, he kept saying that you can't take my family away from me....you can't leave me, he got so angry that he pushed me to the floor, shaking me and then he put his hands around my neck....he didn't hurt me so much, except for being a little sore today from falling on the floor but what do i do know - he left after he did that and apologised and cried like a baby and feels really bad. He said that he would go to counsellling with me if thats what i want.... taking my family away from him will kill him i know this, im just scared that this will happen again.....

    What do i do....

    I'm going to share a story with you from when I was 17 years old. I met a guy, who I thought was amazing. He treated me like noone else ever had, was gorgeous and so sweet. About 3 months into our relationship he started to hit me. First time, he was sorry, never happen again. So I forgave him and let it go. Then it kept happening more and more. One time he even pushed me out of his car, while it was moving. I stayed with him for about a year, mostly out of fear. He told me I could never leave him as he would kill me and my family. I was terrified. Finally one day I gathered up all the courage I had and left. I never looked back. Sure he tried, but my friends, family and myself stood strong and I stayed away. He had me so beaten down that I thought I could do no better. I wasn't worthy of anyone else, only him. BUT I was and STILL AM.

    Of course I had relationships after, but I made myself a promise. NO MAN WOULD EVER HIT ME AGAIN. And no man ever has. I know its the first time its happened, but usually the first time turns into so many more. My advice to you is to leave. It doesn't sound like the relationship is great anyway, since you've already been married 5 months. I know you feel bad because of how he feels for your family and all, but YOU are whats important here...and you are whats important to YOUR family. Don't give him the opportunity to do it again.

    I hope everything works out for you. Be safe.
    True love is an acceptance of all that is, has been, will be and will not be...

  5. #5
    May 2008 "Poster of the Month" Array anonymouswhitefemale's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    1,368
    Blog Entries
    2

    Default

    I'm a guy, and on the whole I think any guy who hits his woman is VERY manipulative. He's say he's sorry, she'll forgive him because people will do anything to stay in a relationship, but she'll then be walking on eggshells because even though he apologised he's still instilled that fear, which he can summon with a look or whatever. Abusers always start slowly, as the longer you know someone the harder it is to leave them, etc etc. In my opinion a man will never only hit his woman once.

    Just leave him, or he'll have you in some psychological state where you feel like a prisoner. Violence (unwanted) has no place in a relationship.

    Also, I'd like to point out, that I can say with certainty that 90% of the people I'm friends with would never consider it, so there are nice people out there. You don't have to settle for people like him.

    Unless you want to of course, and I see a few of those around too.

  6. #6
    TEAM ADMIN Array CHANDLERS WISH's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    19,973
    Blog Entries
    13

    Default

    JUST4ME
    So I forgave him and let it go. Then it kept happening more and more. One time he even pushed me out of his car, while it was moving. I stayed with him for about a year, mostly out of fear
    .

    ANON
    she'll forgive him because people will do anything to stay in a relationship, but she'll then be walking on eggshells
    RCOREYUS
    Someone who resorts to physical violence when upset may do so again.
    I as all know came from an abusive marriage fortunately not physical, although he grabbed my wrists one day when i was cooking and holding a fry pan and wouldn't let go.

    It was at that stage, that i was in true fear, i had spent 7 years remaining married " i believe in marriage" and walking on egg shells 50% of the time, because the other 50% of the time was okay. When i least expected it. Stamping of the feet and verbal abuse for having to many cushions, or not pushing the button on the washing machine, or cleaning stainless steel in the correct stroking manner... Gee!

    So if he could hold my wrists firm and hard, pretty much know what the next step will be.. I left.

    I point this out i guess because i was always full of strength, as i was never a housewife rather a work a holic, so i had my outlet.

    But, 7 years? What a waste and what a silly amount of time to " walk on egg shells", or make matters worse because our personalities obviously didn't match either, as the littlest things got to him, with me, power and control...

    You have only been there 5 months, don't do what i did and stay because " marriage is marriage" or because you want to help him over that hurdle, and put up with it, 7 years says it doesn't and won't change, i tried.

    CW
    Do we not realise that in order to find a soul
    It doesn't happen over night
    if truth were to be told.

    Like everything in life that's hard to achieve
    you must believe!

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Beauty & Style | Fitness & Nutrition | Family & Relationships | Sex & Sexual Health | Physical & Mental Health | Girl Talk | Forum Home
Home | Health Library | Contact | Terms Of Service
© Womens-Health.com 2011+