Forum:

Page 1 of 5 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 42

Thread: Gender Roles

  1. #1
    WH Head Moderator Array WildChild's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Western USA
    Posts
    14,515
    Blog Entries
    6

    Default Gender Roles

    Become a member to remove this ad.
    I've been examining gender roles most of my life in some form. From childhood I had some interests that were considered more 'male', silly designation, really the only totally male thing is fatherhood - I wasn't interested in that. I've know a number of women who do some mechanical work, can swing a hammer, use power tools. I've known some who can just about figure out which end of the screwdriver to hold on to. There are also men like this. As more is learned about the brain, we know that men's and women's are wired differently but that there are individual differences too.

    We have seen a lot of changes over the past century in laws and expectations but in many way the older gender patterns have proved hard to break. They are so embeded in our cultures, religions and languages that it may take a long time to see a truly effective change. I've never been a women's libber but have prefered to ID as a people's libber because any time one group is forced into a particular mold or made subervient, all are negatively affected.

    I'm curious what do you see as female/male roles? Do you see some backsliding? Where do you think we are headed? What would be ideal?

  2. #2
    Registered User Array
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    903
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    you know its funny you ask this question.
    its easier to accept that the woman can handle or adapt or do more manly things than the other way around.
    kind of like the tom-boy. a woman can get dirty, play in the mud, ride a motorcycle and its accepted more and sometimes even sexier.
    (like a woman who wears work-boots and jeans, LOL)
    but if you reversed that and seen the man doing more and more woman things, it isnt as acceptable for whatever reason.
    most guys can adapt to a woman being more universal or adaptable to sitsuations and things but maybe in todays world for a woman to see a guy doing womans things its a turn off and not manly enough.

  3. #3
    Gold Contributor 500+ Posts Array
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    1,084

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by WildChild View Post
    I'm curious what do you see as female/male roles? Do you see some backsliding? Where do you think we are headed? What would be ideal?
    WC, this is a very very touchy subject I think and you know what I'm saying coming from the same generation as I.

    Bottom line, the sexes are different, they are, are they not? I fear to lump them together as the same or reverse the roles is not good or even safe. Mothers should be Mothers, Fathers should be Fathers. They have there roles in life. Maybe you are talking of Women and Men in general but I'm going to hit the subject of Fathers and Mothers, ok?

    Lets take a look at it this way. 1st I'll preface my remarks that I believe in the Creation.

    In the animal kingdom they are creatures that do what they are made to do by instinct, they don't know any different. Man kind was made with a soul to make decisions but within him or herself there is a conscious deep within to do things the way they were created. When that individual comes to the age of accountability they do what they feel of their own choosing. My feeling is the world as a whole has gone astray from those roles. Just because the world has went a certain way does not mean that any individual should go that way. A majority does not make things right all the time!

    I personally don't have a problem of a woman swinging a hammer, I think that's pretty cool. but to think that a Father can raise a child with the same attributes that a Mother would have, I have a problem with that.

    When I was raising a family the wife stayed at home and I was the bread winner so to speak. If the wife had to go to work, ok, but I made it possible where she didn't have to and she didn't want to. Our Kids had security in that.

    Before WWII many women were that way, why?
    That's what made a family unit strong.
    And she didn't mind. The War broke out, men were in the battle field and somebody had to be "Rosy Riveter"... the woman!

    Again I don't have a problem with the woman working and sharing with the decisions in the home. To me it should be a shared strategy, a goal that's accomplished by 2 working side by side.

    I feel the Women is very strong and can accomplish more than the world as a whole will admit. But she has her place as well the Man!

    I'm talking of just 1 aspect of your question here, I'll back off then maybe come back for more!

    But yes we are backsliding, is it good, depends on how you perceive how it should be and what your inner beliefs are!

  4. #4
    WH Super Moderator Array sourpuss's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Montana
    Posts
    3,643

    Default

    I was in K-Mart yesterday, in the toy section...and I kid you not there was a washer/dryer set with a little girl on the box folding a towel with a big smile!! WTF?! And next to it was the same deal, only she was ironing. On the shelf above that was a play work bench with a little boy, of course.

    I couldn't believe it!
    Hard work beats talent, when talent doesn't work hard.

    Register! | Rules/FAQ | Contact Mod

  5. #5
    Administrator Array Little's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    support[at]womens-health[dot]com
    Posts
    3,212

    Default

    I consider high school to be the greatest social experiment on the face of the earth, and I most certainly paid attention.
    It may have been the crowd I ran with, but there are still many factors conditioning both men and women to keep women down. I was in NJROTC all four years. I became the commanding officer (highest rank) my senior year, in charge of a passel of under-disciplined wanna-be Marines. They had to find a coping mechanism (any coping mechanism!) to have a woman in charge of them, and it's kind of funny what they came up with:
    I, apparently, have a penis.
    Not just any penis. A BIG one. The biggest penis of them all. They behaved quite well after coming to this decision. Oh, and it was hilarious. But it also speaks volumes about how some men will go to avoid having a woman be in charge. Even to the point of turning her into a masculine figure. (Not that 16 to 18-year-old boys are men. But they will be someday.)
    I also noticed something about women leading women. Every year that there was a girl in the CO position, one of the freshman girls from that year would become the CO their senior year. There was also much better female cadet retention rates when there were females in charge. Of course, this has only been a 7-year experiment so far but it speaks wonders about giving young women permission to seek leadership positions.
    We are often raised to be chained to our towel-folding and child-raising abilities, not necessarily by our parents but by our culture (and its media) at large. But then we're presented with the idea that stay-at-home moms are lazy or gold-diggers. Gender equality has certainly come a long way but it has a long way left to go.
    Last edited by Little; 01-05-2009 at 09:31 PM.

  6. #6
    Gold Contributor 500+ Posts Array
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    1,084

    Default

    LOL. sourpuss I know what you are saying but really I don't personally look down on a woman that may, lets say take a place in the home full time, or just part time where she is the one who does the laundry and wash and so on. It's an honorable position, I, unlike alot of men don't look at it as being some kind of washer woman. I feel the woman even if she does not work a secular job has a 24/7 job on her hands and it is very honorable. See to me that's part of the problem people have taken the honor out of the so called role of a woman. Maybe I'm not making myself clear, not sure

    Take me now for instance, I've Ironed my own close for yrs. since the days that I was in the Navy and some times I've washed the clothes and done the dishes but if you take the gender out of what a Mother in a what I would call a "Normal Motherly" state then you have the danger of reversing the roles. Is that good, is it?

  7. #7
    TEAM ADMIN Array CHANDLERS WISH's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    19,973
    Blog Entries
    13

    Default

    Grrrr... well said Sourpuss firstly.

    Little, Men can't handle Women as a leader where are the politics going? Who wants to be and can never be? Because men feel they are the better species? sorry anyways.

    Gender?

    Can they at least put the garbage out do you think? 7 and a half years of playing both roles, ahhhh, hense why me single, well not now but you know what I mean.

    CW
    Do we not realise that in order to find a soul
    It doesn't happen over night
    if truth were to be told.

    Like everything in life that's hard to achieve
    you must believe!

  8. #8
    WH Head Moderator Array WildChild's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Western USA
    Posts
    14,515
    Blog Entries
    6

    Default My Little Rant

    This has been interesting so far but not quite what I was looking for. Women in the US actually make a penny less to a man's dollar for doing the same work now than they did 20 yrs ago (think it's 76 cents). The value of Women's unpaid labor world wide is staggering, women employed full time still do the lions share of the housework, child and elder care and are far more likely than men to work in lower paid jobs with few benefits. After a divorce the average woman's (and her children) standard of living drops close to 50%, the average man's rises by 10% with a divorce. Women are more likely to live in poverty both before and after retirement. Women in college continue to enroll in majors that lead to lower paying work. While there are some individual stellar examples of female success, statistically we aren't doing much.

    Add to this the cultural swing that has taken place of women actually objectifying themselves. We are seeing not a healthy body acceptance and increase in sexual satisfaction but a 700% increase in breast enhancement surgery and women working hard at sexually pleasing men (or imitating how they think men act sexually) - not themselves. I see women using sexual imagery and behavior to get ahead in the work place and many masculinizing themselves in an effort to succeed. These were some of the problems supposedly faced and talked to death early in the so called women's movement.

    Where are we headed with this? Why is it happening? Are we making progress? Toward what?

    I'm a member of a more localised and restricted (no men) women's Q &A type forum and the young women seem to be abandoning ship right and left and withdrawing into lives that look a lot like what our mothers or grandmothers had - except most of them also seem to lack the survival skills of a good housewife. They can't or don't cook, bake, sew, do yard work, or clean and are often clueless about the most basic childcare or rearing issues. But they are married and expect their husbands to come home from work and relieve them so they can "have a life". I don't get it. If wife and mother is their chosen work - why aren't they striving to do it well?

    We've got an insane number of people on drugs for depression (women's numbers are higher than mens by far). We are in a time of great transistion but it seems that a lot of women (and many men) have simply given up taking real responsiblity for owning their lives. We should (we are but in a arre way) be moving toward a greater range of opportunity for both genders. The intense sexualisation of young girls (who buys their clothes anyway?) the stuff you see on TV and in magazines, makes you wonder what on earth is going on? I rarely see any of the 'reality' shows , what I have seen makes me sick. There are people sitting on their fat fannies eating this stuff up and thinking this is life?!

    We are on the verge with some fantastic stuff. We should be excited and feel like we are moving forward, not sitting around obessing over how to afford lipo or a boob job - who wants the kind of man that will attract anyway? What is going on? Do I just live a strange area where the juxtaposition of Focus on the Family and the brave new world, have created some odd situation? Looking at all the magazine covers this looks to be widespread. I'm no conservative, I want to see change but for crying out loud, where is the rational for much of this? Learning pole dancing doesn't make a woman more sexually responsive it's just different marketing.

    For a while we looked like things were really moving. As a girl I had to fight to take drafting classes (and I paid a heavy price for invading the 'male' world - gang rape for one) now courses like that are easily accessible to girls - are they taking them? My daughter is brilliant, strong in math and science but still torn over acceptance issues with the idea of going to college for those fields. She was teased in grade school for being smart and became less sure of herself and started hiding her abilties (she forgot her calculator when taking the ACTs so she "only" scored in the 98 percentile - the idea that most kids wouldn't have attempted the math w/o a calculator doesn't occur to her) I see similar patterns with her girl freinds most of whom are very bright but few are really motivated to DO anything with it or even see their own potential.

    The contrast I see with my son is remarkable, he's 3 years from graduation and has already decided that he will go to MIT on a full scholarship, his belief in this is absolute. His sister was told by a woman in the counseling office not to 'waste time' applying to Harvard or Yale despite the fact that the schools sent her apps without her requesting them. The idea that the worst that could happen is that she wouldn't get accepted but that without applying there is no chance at all, doesn't seem to be on the table with the school (this is one of the top ranked HS in the US). I can't help but wonder what a boy with her academic record would have been encouraged to do.

    I know there is more opportunity in some ways but what are we as women, as parents, as singles or life partners doing to facilitate things? Are you seeing positive change? Am I just sleep deprived and seeing a limited picture? Has spending several years as an unappreciated care provider to a man warped my perception? Believe it or not a woman ran for president in the 1800s (before women had the vote) - how far have we really come? What do you think it will take to really create substantive positive change? What kind of world can we create in the time we have? We are the primary care givers, teachers, child rearers - we can change the world, what are we doing?

    (understand I am playing the devil's advocate here - I'll probably pop up later with some good stuff on what we are doing)

  9. #9
    Gold Contributor 500+ Posts Array
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    1,084

    Default

    I started to make a big spill on this topic but I have a feeling I'm on the loosing end, My post #3 and #6 are still very vital to what you are saying WC, regardless if you think it's not!

    There are some basics involved here. Full Stop!

  10. #10
    Gold Contributor 500+ Posts Array
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    1,084

    Default

    ok, I know you are talking statistics and I don't know them, couldn't begin to dispute them if I wanted to........

    I agree tho, the woman has not had a fair play, ok! I see that, I do, but to answer your question about the economics issues, which is some of the points you are hitting. It will only be improved if you women get together in a greater way other than the so called "womens lib" movement.

    It needs to have a different face, a different tittle if you will.

    Read John Adams by Page Smith, 2 volumes, I've read it twice and you will see what Abigail Adams had to say about these type of issues. And we are talking pre 1776.

    It will have to come thru women collectively getting together with a different approach and a different Name so to speak concerning issues that you have bro't up.

    It can come thru the man if the right women is behind the man, again Page Smith.

    Women, few do know, have changed History, because of who they were associated with, marriage or what have you! They have not got the credit for it. But, if it gets changed for the better of women who cares. If Women do care then it boils down to a matter of pride of who gets the credit.

    Am I off on this as far as the Thread goes, this is what I'm reading. You have written so many points, its hard, for me at least, to cipher thru it all.

Page 1 of 5 123 ... LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Influencing baby's gender
    By patricias213 in forum Pregnancy
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 02-27-2007, 07:17 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Beauty & Style | Fitness & Nutrition | Family & Relationships | Sex & Sexual Health | Physical & Mental Health | Girl Talk | Forum Home
Home | Health Library | Contact | Terms Of Service
© Womens-Health.com 2011+