I like a man in a smart suit or just casual shirt and trousers. BUT I actually prefer him looking more relaxed in a good pair of jeans, not too tight or baggy, with a belt and nice shirt, top button or two left undone (not like medallion man though!), good shoes/boots, nice watch (no digital's). Or in loose-fitting shorts (with sexy tanned legs) and short sleeved shirt (top buttons undone) with open toed sandals. OR just wearing shorts (with a well toned upper body and legs as mentioned above!)
And smelling of something like Davidoff Cool Water Mmmmmmm....
Preferably no hair styling product as I like hair to look and feel clean. No earrings or dangly wrist/neck jewellery, but a simple gold or silver chain is good. No facial hair and as little body hair as poss. (Feel like I'm advertising for a man now :grin
However if I really liked the guy's personality I wouldn't turn my back because he was wearing the wrong kind of shoes (or watch haha).
But I would if he looked dirty or smelled bad lol.