Hey Justlikeheaven,
FYI this guy seems like he is ignoring you cause really he is playing the cat and mouse game of you want him more than he wants you. Congrats on your decision to wait its the best one.
To clairify your question can you fall for someone you know you should YES! Its called "bad boy syndrom" and us women we have all been there at some point with our battle story to tell lol.
No worries you will meet your "first" a man who wants it to be fun and exciting for you not a guy who seems like he wants the bragging rights of bagging a virgin.
best of luck hun