Fleshlight Vs. Onahole: How They Compare (And Which Is Better)

Fleshlights and onaholes, designed in Japan, are both popular pocket pussies. Which feels better depends on who you ask and what they’ve tried.
split-screen image featuring fleshlights on the left and anime onaholes on the right with company logos attached to each slide
We independently research and vet everything we recommend. Our team is supported by affiliate commissions. Learn more →
Updated:August 2023

If you want to switch up your sexual routine with a variety of options, both an onahole and Fleshlight are a great way to do it because they’re both pocket pussies that offer sensations similar to vaginal, anal, or oral sex.

Although Fleshlights look like a standard utility flashlight, onaholes don’t feature a case — designed in Japan and sold (and shipped) overseas, many of them play into fantasies surrounding anime characters.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Fleshlight is a realistic masturbation sleeve or pocket pussy, made in the USA, which features a flashlight-like exterior that hides an inner sleeve resembling a vagina, anus, mouth, or occasionally nothing in particular.
  • The onahole is a style of masturbation sleeve designed in Japan, offered by many brands and typically sold from overseas, featuring a design that often goes beyond the genitals (including full-body replicas of anime characters).
  • Both Fleshlights and onaholes are designed for penetration, but only Fleshlight uses patented body-safe Super Skin. Onaholes might be made from a variety of sex toy materials (some of which may not be body-safe), particularly TPE blends, which are porous and may contain harmful chemicals.
  • Due to being produced overseas by non-vetted retailers, an onahole toy may be a risky choice compared to a reputable brand like Fleshlight.

While the Fleshlight is popular in the US, the onahole is a Japanese invention that is gaining traction in mainstream America.

It’s a close battle between Fleshlight vs. onahole to figure out which sex toy is the better option, and the answer depends on the product, your needs, and your preferences.

Fleshlight Vs. Onahole: A Side-By-Side Comparison

split screen image of fleshlights on the left and an onahole on the right

The difference between a Fleshlight and onahole is more than you might imagine, considering their similarities.

Take a look at the comparison chart below to help you make a more sound decision on whether a Fleshlight or onahole is right for you.

Fleshlight Vs. Onahole
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Onahole
Onahole
Price Range
$10-100+
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth, full-body
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Limited ethnicities, colors
Texture Options
Many
Some
Design
Discreet with case
Not discreet, no case
Realism
Very realistic
Mid to high
Functionality
Manual or vibrating
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
Low to mid
Warranty
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
No
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
Not guaranteed

 

Both onahole and Fleshlight can provide penis owners with giddy anticipation towards their next masturbation sesh, bringing a whole new sensation to jerking off, so there’s really no right answer to which one is better.

It all depends on what will lead you personally to a more explosive orgasm.

Advantages Of A Fleshlight

While the onahole has no shortage of creative options, the Fleshlight has remained the top dog in terms of quality for decades now.

In some ways, it also provides a totally different sensation that some people may prefer.

The benefits of using a Fleshlight include:

  • Discretion, with most models being kept inside a plain, flashlight-like case.
  • Easy to hold on to, thanks to the ridged handle along the case.
  • A case that protects the soft inner sleeve, extending its longevity and providing better storage (and easier hiding).
  • More color/ethnicity options.
  • Tighter fit in some models and softer, one-of-a-kind material that is body-safe (and patented).
  • Greater range of features and sleeve textures.
  • Most models feature an air valve at the bottom of the case that regulates suction and tightness.
  • Remarkable, fast-responding customer service.
  • Reputable brand manufactured in the USA.

Despite offering the tightest feel out there, the Fleshlight may be less portable compared to some onahole models, and it may also have more components to clean and dry, depending on the product.

That said, Fleshlights are manufactured by one brand, using body-safe materials, and have a reputation for quality and good customer service — all of which may be lacking from an onahole.

Advantages Of An Onahole

Although the average onahole just looks like a pocket pussy and pretty much resembles a Fleshlight without the hard case, they aren’t the same.

The benefits of using an onahole include:

  • No bulky case to maneuver (or clean).
  • More control over squeeze and tightness, with most models.
  • Can be easier to clean, depending on the product’s design (partial or full torsos require much more effort).
  • Generally more flexible to store, although some models are bulky if they provide more than just a basic genital sleeve.
  • Can be ideal for those who prefer the feel or control of a handjob, as well as those looking for a full-body experience from something more akin to a sex doll.
  • May fit into partnered play more seamlessly without the hard plastic case, and can add the sensation of a threesome, depending on the model.
  • Feels similar to a real vagina, anus, or mouth.
  • Many (and very creative) options to choose from, including singular body parts, partial or full torsos, anime characters, and Japanese porn stars.

Although the onahole can be suitable for those who don’t want a hard exterior and prefer a full-body feeling akin to using a sex doll, there’s no protection for the sleeves, which can be delicate and easily damaged.

Additionally, cleaning the full body or torso/booty cheek options can be a headache.

Onahole products also don’t offer a specific cleaning solution unlike Fleshlight, which sells its own, although most sex toy cleaners are likely to be compatible, depending on the materials.

On that note, onaholes can be made from a variety of sex toy materials that may or may not be safe — and they may not be accurately disclosed, either.

Additionally, not too many well-known, trusted US retailers sell them.

Onaholes are mostly sold overseas, sometimes from shady retailers, with no quality or customer service guarantee attached.

The Difference Between Fleshlights & Onaholes

Although they’re both masturbation strokers designed with the purpose of penetration, the main difference between a Fleshlight and onahole lies in where they’re manufactured and the style of design.

Onaholes were popularized in Japan, whereas Fleshlights are more common in the United States, where they’re manufactured.

What Is A Fleshlight?

photograph of fleshlight pink lady heavenly

A play on the word flashlight, a Fleshlight consists of an inner sleeve and a hard outer case that resembles a flashlight, hence the name.

The inner sleeve of a Fleshlight is made from the brand’s very own Super Skin, a high-quality material that feels extremely similar to the body part it emulates.

Designed for penetration, Fleshlights come in all shapes, sizes, and orifices and can mimic vaginal, anal, and oral sex, depending on the model.

According to one of our writers and reviewers, it’s a pleasurable alternative to using your hand.

Fleshlights are manufactured in the USA and are known for their powerful suction and tightness, which provides a realistic simulation of sex.

What Is An Onahole?

stock image of an onahole masturbator beside its product box, which features an anime character and japanese writing

An onahole is a male masturbation toy and pocket pussy for men that comes from Japan.

It was originally designed by Otona Japan, which has been a best-selling adult toy business company since 1991.

Like the Fleshlight, an onahole is made of a pliable, soft sleeve and designed to be penetrated.

While onaholes are commonly shaped like a woman’s vagina, you can find them in mouth and butthole variations to simulate fellatio and anal sex.

Some models go beyond the basic pocket pussy design and are made with a midsection, including a torso, breasts, buttcheeks, and lower back.

This full-body experience provides a lifelike realism that the tube shape of a Fleshlight cannot.

The more realistic and beautiful an onahole is considered to be, the more likely it is to be referred to as “meiki” – which means gorgeous or superb in Japanese.

Some onahole models take on an anime persona, while others emulate popular Japanese adult stars.

Rather than being made by one brand like the Fleshlight, however, onaholes are available from tons of manufacturers.

Unlike Fleshlight’s patented (and trusted) Super Skin, these portable pussies are often made from silicone (or claim to be), thermoplastic elastomers (TPE), or thermoplastic rubber (TPR).

They can also be made from other unknown (and often undisclosed) material blends.

The range of ethnicities and colors is not as varied as Fleshlight, but there are still many options available online.

How To Choose Between Fleshlight And An Onahole

photograph of the riley reid utopia texture fleshlight box on a white table beside the uncapped pocket pussy with the vulva side facing the viewer

While Fleshlights feel incredible to those who enjoy them, they’re often tighter than a human vagina and don’t always provide much space to maneuver.

An onahole, on the other hand, isn’t as tight because it isn’t contained in a hard case and can provide a more realistic sensation of sex — especially if a partial or full torso is attached.

If you’re still not sure which you should try, we’ll share the key details to keep in mind.

You might prefer a Fleshlight if you:

  • Prefer a pocket pussy or stroker that’s discreet and easily hidden.
  • Like the sleeve protection provided by a hard external case.
  • Want as many features as possible and a more customizable experience, since you can swap sleeves.
  • Prefer to choose from a variety of different ethnicities or colors.
  • Want the tightest experience possible with maximum suction, which is adjustable with most models.
  • Prefer to choose from a range of exciting internal textures and porn star anatomies.
  • Worry about unsafe sex toy materials in products from lesser-known brands.
  • Want to buy from reputable American retailers you trust.

You might prefer an Onahole if you:

  • Don’t want to come as fast, as they’re generally not as tight as a Fleshlight.
  • Prefer the feeling of vaginal, anal, or oral sex without looking at a plastic case.
  • Want more space and flexibility to move your penis around inside the sleeve.
  • Seek more of a full-body experience, including realistic body parts to hold onto.
  • Want to manually control speed, tightness, and intensity.
  • Like an anime-inspired product or have favorite Japanese porn stars.
  • Are not concerned about the sex toy materials used — or their relative safety.

In terms of answering the question, “Which is better, onahole or Fleshlight?” it all comes down to personal preference, and masturbation is a totally subjective experience.

Consider what you’re searching for in a stroker or pocket pussy to find which option ticks all your boxes.

What Feels Better: Fleshlight Or Onahole?

As with anything relating to sex, what feels better (or doesn’t) is entirely subjective based on who you ask, and the same holds true when choosing between a Fleshlight or an onahole.

Although the onahole has benefits that include creative designs, larger body areas (including full torsos) and no unsightly plastic case, the quality and reputation of the Fleshlight speaks for itself.

Many people prefer the Fleshlight because of the tighter fit, durability, and wide range of options within a single site — which is easier to navigate compared to dozens of different brands and websites.

If you want a cheaper option (and more of a full-body experience) and customer service and product quality aren’t your main concern, you might consider an onahole.

In the Fleshlight vs. meiki debate, there isn’t necessarily a clear winner, only what appeals to you.

However, due to the brand’s reputation, the toy’s long-lasting nature, and our team’s own experience, we recommend the Fleshlight as the superior toy in terms of quality and customer support.

Best Fleshlights To Try

If you’re looking for a new Fleshlight — whether buying one for the first time or replacing a beloved favorite — our top recommendations below are the perfect place to start.

photograph of fleshlight pink lady heavenlyClassic Pink Lady Heavenly

While there are certainly more complex Fleshlights available, this pretty-in-pink vaginal sleeve is the best full-size beginner option to try.

This original Fleshlight has stood the test of time for a reason and the classic Heavenly texture is loved by penises around the world.

photograph of a clear fleshlight quickshotFleshlight Quickshot

The textured Quickshot is the smallest Fleshlight available — and is also the best handjob hybrid to start with.

It comes in vaginal, anal, oral, porn star, and non-anatomy styles so there’s something for everyone.

With a variable grip, the Quickshot is open-ended and comes in both realistic and see-through sleeves, making it the best portable, travel-friendly, discreet model to explore.

product photograph of the fleshlight universal launchFleshlight Universal Launch & Quickshot Launch

For those looking for an automatic, hands-free experience, the Launch is a splurge you won’t regret.

The Universal Launch fits all full-sized Fleshlight models while the Quickshot Launch accommodates (you guessed it) all Quickshots.

Fleshlight Girls: Riley Reid Utopia

The Riley Reid Fleshlight, designed after its namesake porn star, is one of the most popular Fleshlight Girls.

Utopia (Vulva)
Riley Reid Utopia
4.8
$79.99
Pros:
  • Feels Incredible & Surprisingly Realistic
  • Unique Interior Texture
  • Simple to Use, Adjustable Suction
  • Pretty Easy to Clean
Cons:
  • Noisier Than Expected
  • Cleaning Takes More Work Than Regular Masturbation
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: Featuring an unbelievably sexy vulva (signed by Riley Reid!), this is one of the most popular Fleshlight Girl models for a reason. Intuitive to use, the innovative skin-like sleeve texture is unique and totally blew our expectations for Fleshlights out of the water.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $79.99 @ Adam & Eve

Where To Buy An Onahole

Amazon is the most well-known retailer where you can buy an onahole easily, as most US sex toy retailers don’t carry them.

That said, shopping for sex toys on Amazon is always a bit of a risk in terms of what you pay for, and what you get, so be sure to read customer reviews thoroughly before buying.

While some independent foreign retailers sell onaholes, there’s no guarantee that they’ll show up on your doorstep as promised — this goes for both the product quality and the window of time they’ll arrive in.

You might be waiting weeks (or months) for your purchase to arrive after ordering from overseas, not to mention the shipping costs that may be involved.

Additionally, these products are sometimes available for purchase only in foreign currencies, and you may be charged customs fees and additional costs when they arrive, depending on where you live.

Closing Thoughts

Is an onahole better than Fleshlight?

In our eyes (and the eyes of many others), it’s a probable no.

Ultimately, Fleshlight’s reputation and dedication to its customer base sets this American manufacturer above its foreign competitors.

Rather than spend your money on something you may already be skeptical about, browse the many options that Fleshlight offers.

If you find the brand a little pricey, there are plenty of other pocket pussies from vetted retailers being sold at a very affordable price and made by well-known brands.

Editor’s Note: This article is part of our Complete Guide To Fleshlights and Everything Fleshlight hub, in-depth and evolving resources that comprehensively explore and review all aspects of Fleshlights from the company’s discreet billing and shipping, to the types of products they carry, how to use them, materials, and safety.