Fleshlight Vs. Other Masturbators: How They Compare (And Which Is Better)

Fleshlights and other male masturbators are popular and the selection varies widely. Opinions vary on which feels better.
split-screen image featuring two fleshlights on the left with the company logo and three different masturbators on the right, autoblow, main squeeze, and blewit, with text that reads "vs" between both sides of the image
We independently research and vet everything we recommend. Our team is supported by affiliate commissions. Learn more →
Updated:December 2023

A Fleshlight is one of the most popular pocket pussies and male masturbators available, featuring a signature flashlight-style case hiding a soft inner sleeve that provides realistic vaginal, anal, or oral sex.

But they’re not the only strokers out there and there’s a long list of amazing products that can feel just as good — if not better, depending on your preferences.

If you want to jump straight to the product you’re most curious about, click any link in the list below:

Key Takeaways:

  • Fleshlights have many similarities when compared with other pocket pussies, masturbators, and strokers, but given the sheer number of available products from other sex toy manufacturers, there truly is something for everyone.
  • Fleshlights are made with proprietary Super Skin material and most models feature a lifelike vaginal, anal, or mouth orifice for the most realistic experience possible.
  • Other masturbators may be made from a variety of sex toy materials (not all of them necessarily good or safe) but the sheer range of products, and the features they offer, can make them a good option for those seeking toys that are unique, interactive, or custom-designed.
  • Choosing between a Fleshlight and another masturbator ultimately comes down to your budget along with the toy’s features, aesthetics, customization, and the type of experience you’re looking for.

Although Fleshlights are one of the most well-known brands of male masturbators, they’re just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to pleasure.

We’ll compare Fleshlights against a number of other masturbators you’ve likely heard of, including Doc Johnson, Kiiroo, and Bad Dragon, to name a few, and talk about their benefits, how to choose, and which feels best.

Fleshlight Vs. Others: A Side-By-Side Comparison

Fleshlights are pretty similar to some male masturbators (we’re looking at you, Main Squeeze and Kiiroo), but vastly different compared to others.

Below, we’ll offer quick comparisons for:

Doc Johnson Main Squeeze Vs. Fleshlight

product photograph of the doc johnson main squeeze masturbator
Fleshlight Vs. Main Squeeze
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Main Squeeze
Main Squeeze
Fleshlight
Price Range
$35-$124.95
$35-$200+
Material
Trademarked ULTRASKYN
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Discreet with case
Discreet with case
Realism
Very realistic
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual or vibrating
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
High
Warranty
Up to 90 days
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
High

 

It’s clear that Fleshlights have influenced the design choices of the Main Squeeze line from Doc Johnson, but when you’ve got a good thing, imitation is probably the sincerest form of flattery.

The Main Squeeze line is very comparable to Fleshlights, including some of the porn stars who have modeled for the series.

One benefit that the Main Squeeze offers beyond what Fleshlight does is the inclusion of cam girls and social media stars.

Fleshlight Pro offered those once upon a time — and will again — but if you’re searching for your favorite stars (who aren’t porn stars), the Main Squeeze wins this round.

Bad Dragon Vs. Fleshlight

product photo of a bad dragon fantasy masturbation sleeve featuring an alien-like tentacle in shades of orange and red
Fleshlight Vs. Bad Dragon
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Bad Dragon
Bad Dragon
Fleshlight
Price Range
Base starts at $100
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Varies
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Multi; works of art
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Stunningly beautiful
Discreet with case
Realism
Fantasy-inspired
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
High
Warranty
1-year
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
No
Yes
Durability
High
High

 

If you’re looking to stick your dick into something beautiful and fantastical, Bad Dragon wins, hands-down.

The entire line of customizable masturbators not only lets you select your base model (or monster!) but the colors and firmness of the silicone-cast toys as well.

Fleshlights are ideal when you’re craving some human-like loving, but if you’re in the mood to make love to a monster… Bad Dragon is where it’s at.

Fleshlight offers its limited Freaks series around Halloween, but they don’t compare to the stunning works of art Bad Dragon creates.

Kiiroo Vs. Fleshlight

image featuring various images of kiiroo keon sleeves with its case
Fleshlight Vs. Kiiroo
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Kiiroo
Kiiroo
Fleshlight
Price Range
$69-$229
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities, solid black
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Discreet with case
Discreet with case
Realism
Very realistic
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual, vibrating, automatic, interactive
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
High
Warranty
Replacement, no refunds
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
High

 

Kiiroo is beyond well-known in the world of interactive and virtual reality sex toys, so it’s no surprise that they offer their own range of male masturbators, including Keon, Titan, and Onyx.

In fact, the original Fleshlight Launch (no longer available) was designed in partnership with Kiiroo, pairing Fleshlight’s signature strokers with Kiiroo’s technology.

Although both offer a lot in terms of pleasure, if you’re looking for something with the greatest amount of interactivity, including partner play from a distance, Kiiroo is the best choice.

Shop Kiiroo

Fleshjack Vs. Fleshlight

split screen image of two porn actors who have fleshjacks modeled after their anatomy, representing part of the fleshjack line of products
Fleshlight Vs. Fleshjack
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Fleshjack
Fleshjack
Fleshlight
Price Range
$35-$200+
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Anus, mouth, or dildo
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Discreet with case
Discreet with case
Realism
Very realistic
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual or vibrating
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
High
Warranty
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
High

 

Designed by Fleshlight, Fleshjacks are the brand’s line of masturbators aimed at men who prefer to have sex with other men.

Fleshjacks, also known as “gay Fleshlights,” offer anal and mouth orifices for penetration, along with hyper-realistic dildos modeled after some of the most popular porn stars.

Whether a Fleshlight or Fleshjack is better ultimately depends on who you prefer to have sex with — or your orifices of choice.

→ Shop Fleshjack

Autoblow Vs. Fleshlight

photograph of three autoblow sleeves and boxes with the autoblow automatic stroker to the right
Fleshlight Vs. Autoblow
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Autoblow
Autoblow
Fleshlight
Price Range
$49.95-$299.95
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Beige or brown
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Few
Many
Design
Not discreet
Discreet with case
Realism
Fairly realistic
Very realistic
Functionality
Automatic and AI-enabled
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Medium
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
High
Warranty
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
High

 

The Autoblow takes masturbation to a new level by simulating more than 25 blowjob simulations, although your sleeve of choice can be vaginal, anal, or oral.

The price tag is high on these because they’re fully automated and offer a range of sensations, speeds, and stroke types.

In that way, they’re more immersive and realistic compared to Fleshlights — which can be automated using their Launch models (Universal and Quickshot).

That said, Autoblow sleeves can’t easily be used by hand unless you physically hold the sleeve — they don’t have cases for manual use.

Fifi Vs. Fleshlight

aerial photograph of a diy fleshlight made from a pringles can, sponges, and glove
Fleshlight Vs. Fifi
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Fifi
Fifi
Fleshlight
Price Range
Free (basically)
$35-$200+
Material
Whatever you have around
Orifice Type(s)
Nondescript
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Varies
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Depends on crafting skills
Discreet with case
Realism
Low
Very realistic
Functionality
Minimal
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Generally not applicable
Depends on model
Overall Quality
Low to medium
High
Warranty
N/A
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Not really
Yes
Durability
Low to medium
High

 

A fifi (pronounced fee-fee) is a handmade DIY Fleshlight that’s essentially made from whatever materials you have laying around.

Unless you’re an expert crafter, a fifi is really not an especially “competitive” masturbator when paired against a realistic, high-quality Fleshlight.

That said, money is an object for many and sometimes a fifi is the cheapest and easiest option — and there’s no shame in that.

Sex Doll Vs. Fleshlight

Closeup Photograph Of Eve The Girl Next Door Torso And Its Box
Fleshlight Vs. Sex Doll
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Sex Doll
Sex Doll
Fleshlight
Price Range
$29.99 to $3,000+
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Not discreet
Discreet with case
Realism
Varies
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Complex
Depends on model
Overall Quality
Low to high
High
Warranty
Varies
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
Low to high
High

 

You might be curious about the price range of sex dolls but we’ll put it this way: anything that’s super affordable and less than $100 is likely a blow-up doll.

(Not that they don’t have a place in people’s hearts, but they’re generally not very realistic and often used as a gag gift.)

There are also some pretty decent mid-range products, like Eve The Girl Next Door, sold at Adam & Eve.

Top-Rated
Eve The Girl Next Door Realistic Torso Eve The Girl Next Door Realistic Torso
4.7
$199.99
Bottom Line: Eve The Girl Next Door is a top-rated masturbator for a reason! Her material feels like real skin and the size and weight of her torso will make you feel like you’re not alone in bed. With a soft vaginal opening, a tight anus, and full breasts for squeezing, she's got everything you need (and she's ready to give it to you all night)!

High-quality sex dolls will run into the thousands in terms of monetary price and they are anything but discreet.

Sex dolls, after all, are designed to be as lifelike as possible — size and all.

That said, they offer a more full-body experience than a Fleshlight could dream of providing — unless the company breaks into the sex doll business in the future.

Blewit Vs. Fleshlight

product photograph of the blewit masturbator with its cap off
Fleshlight Vs. Blewit
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Blewit
Blewit
Fleshlight
Price Range
~$58
$35-$200+
Orifice Type(s)
Nondescript hole
Vagina, anus, mouth
Color Options
Blue and white
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
N/A
Many
Design
Discreet with case
Discreet with case
Realism
Not realistic
Very realistic
Functionality
Manual
Manual or vibrating
Ease Of Cleaning
Fairly simple
Depends on model
Overall Quality
Medium
High
Warranty
Based on retailer
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Accessories Available?
No
Yes
Durability
Medium-High
High

 

Blewit is a rather hard-to-find masturbator (it’s out of stock at all vendors we found who carry it, as of this writing).

Compared to the Fleshlight, Blewit is a rather rudimentary-looking stroker, featuring a simple hole at the center of the orifice.

The sterile blue and white standard coloring is less than sexy but if you can get past that, it might be a great affordable option compared to a Fleshlight.

If you seek the most realistic feel, however — especially with the sexy visual of a vulva, anus, or mouth — a Fleshlight is the best tool to get the job done.

Advantages Of A Fleshlight

Fleshlights are an innovative pocket pussy that’s been around for decades and the discreet yet realistic pleasure they offer is what has made them so popular to its customer base.

The products are high-quality and durable, easy enough to take care of and provide a pretty realistic simulation of vaginal, anal, or oral sex.

The benefits of a Fleshlight include: 

Advantages Of Other Masturbators

Although Fleshlights offer a lot to those who enjoy them, other masturbators provide plenty of unique experiences in their own right and depending on what you’re looking for, might be perfect.

Benefits of non-Fleshlight masturbators include:

  • A wider range of product types to suit just about any preference you might have
  • A wider range of price points from extremely affordable to break-the-bank expensive
  • Some models provide a more customizable design experience (Bad Dragon)
  • Some masturbators provide better interactive capabilities — including control by a partner from any distance (Kiiroo)
  • Some non-Fleshlight strokers provide automation that feels realistic, offering a range of preset stroking styles to choose from (Autoblow)

There are so many pocket pussies and masturbators out there, you’d be hard-pressed to find something you won’t love — but it’s worth exploring the entire internet catalog to find it.

The hardest part is going to be choosing one.

The Difference Between Fleshlights And Other Masturbators

Fleshlights are a branded type of masturbator, but they’re not the end-all-be-all when it comes to options available.

Sex toy retailers around the world make a variety of pocket pussies (like onahole), strokers (such as Tenga) and Fleshlight-like toys to choose from.

What Is A Fleshlight?

photograph of product tester justin unscrewing the bottom cap of the riley reid utopia pocket pussy, which can adjust suction during use and be removed completely during cleaning

Offering closed and open-ended models, Fleshlight is the only toy on the market to feature its proprietary Super Skin, an ultra-soft but durable material that all of their products are molded from.

For many, a Fleshlight feels as close to real vaginal, anal, or oral penetration as possible.

Other Types Of Masturbators

Many sex toy manufacturers offer male masturbators, sleeves, pocket pussies, and strokers including the Tenga and onahole, that essentially do the same thing — provide pleasure by imitating vaginal, anal, or oral penetration, along with handjobs.

Masturbators are crafted by too many companies to count, but some of the most well-known include Doc Johnson, Kiiroo, Bad Dragon, and Autoblow, to name just a few.

How To Choose Between Fleshlight And Other Masturbators

photograph of product tester justin squinting as he looks inside of the riley reid utopia fleshlight

When it comes to pleasure and masturbation, Fleshlights and other strokers offer a lot but it can be difficult to choose between them, considering the sheer number of products available.

You might prefer a Fleshlight if you:

  • Want an extensive range of textures and visual aesthetics that include a human-like vulva, anus, or mouth opening.
  • Are looking for the most realistic simulation of vaginal, anal, or oral sex.
  • Prefer a discreet sleeve that’s kept safe inside an exterior case.
  • Seek a masturbator or stroker that offers adjustable suction.
  • Want to explore fantasies revolving around your favorite porn stars.
  • Prefer a manual stroker with an option for automation through an accessory.
  • Don’t mind the cleaning and maintenance required.

You might prefer a different masturbator if you:

  • Want a huge variety of shapes, sizes, and styles to choose from.
  • Are looking for something that is entirely customizable, right down to the color and texture of your sex toy. (Bad Dragon)
  • Seek a masturbator that offers interactive, VR, or remote controlled partner play. (Kiiroo)
  • Want a device that mimics blowjobs using varied suction and movement. (Autoblow)
  • Are interested in finding a full-body option that goes beyond more than a single orifice. (Sex dolls)
  • Want to choose from options that are easier to clean, dry, or maintain with products you already have at home.

There’s no wrong answer, but you’ll need to decide what it is that you want from your masturbator, before you choose the best one for yourself.

What Feels Better: Fleshlight Or Other Masturbators?

As with any sex toy, a person’s preferences are entirely subjective — so there’s no clear-cut answer to the question of which feels better, a Fleshlight or [insert-your-masturbator-here].

Our best advice is to try a Fleshlight and a couple of other strokers to see what you think about them, and how they compare to one another.

Best Fleshlights To Try

If you’re looking for a new Fleshlight — whether buying one for the first time or replacing a beloved favorite — our top recommendations below are the perfect place to start.

photograph of fleshlight pink lady heavenlyClassic Pink Lady Heavenly

While Fleshlight offers a variety of product options, this classic pink vaginal sleeve has been around for years, remaining a consistent favorite among connoisseurs.

The “heavenly” texture inside is loved by plenty of Fleshlight fans, old and new, and it’s a great beginner option if you’ve never used one before.

photograph of a clear fleshlight quickshotFleshlight Quickshot

The Quickshot is the smallest Fleshlight model available, sized at just 3.5″ long.

It offers genital orifices (including some of the most popular porn stars) as well as non-anatomical styles if you prefer.

The Quickshot is open-ended on both sides and comes in both realistic and see-through sleeves.

product photograph of the fleshlight universal launchFleshlight Universal Launch & Quickshot Launch

For those looking for an automatic, hands-free experience with their Fleshlight, the Launch series works with full-sized models (Universal Launch) and Quickshots (Quickshot Launch).

Either one is perfect for automated stroking but you must use the model that fits your Fleshlight correctly — the Universal Launch won’t work with Quickshots, nor will full-sized Fleshlights work with the Quickshot Launch.

Fleshlight Girls: Riley Reid Utopia

The Riley Reid Fleshlight, designed after its namesake porn star, was loved by our testing team for its gorgeous vulva and exciting internal texture.

Utopia (Vulva)
Riley Reid Utopia
4.8
$79.99
Pros:
  • Feels Incredible & Surprisingly Realistic
  • Unique Interior Texture
  • Simple to Use, Adjustable Suction
  • Pretty Easy to Clean
Cons:
  • Noisier Than Expected
  • Cleaning Takes More Work Than Regular Masturbation
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: Featuring an unbelievably sexy vulva (signed by Riley Reid!), this is one of the most popular Fleshlight Girl models for a reason. Intuitive to use, the innovative skin-like sleeve texture is unique and totally blew our expectations for Fleshlights out of the water.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $79.99 @ Adam & Eve

Where To Buy Other Masturbators And Strokers

If you’d rather purchase a masturbator that isn’t a Fleshlight, our most trusted vendors offer a variety to choose from, including:

Closing Thoughts

Fleshlights, pocket pussies, and masturbators offer more variety for pleasure than we can conceivably keep track of, and they’re all fantastic to those who enjoy using them.

If you’re not sure what you’ll prefer more, we suggest trying out a few different ones, as it’s the only way to discover for yourself what feels best.

Fleshlights are amazing, but so are plenty of other male masturbation toys — the world is your oyster, so go forth and try some on for size!

Editor’s Note: This article is part of our Complete Guide To Fleshlights and Everything Fleshlight hub, in-depth and evolving resources that comprehensively explore and review all aspects of Fleshlights from the company’s discreet billing and shipping, to the types of products they carry, how to use them, materials, and safety.