Fleshlight Vs. Pocket Pussy: How They Compare (And Which Is Better)

Fleshlight is a brand, while a pocket pussy is a type of stroker that includes Fleshlights. Which feels better depends on who you ask, but both feel good.
split-screen image showing a fleshlight on the left and a generic pocket pussy on the right with text that reads "vs" in the center
We independently research and vet everything we recommend. Our team is supported by affiliate commissions. Learn more →
Updated:January 2024

For many, the terms Fleshlight and pocket pussy are interchangeable.

They’re both portable masturbation sleeves that resemble a vagina and provide a mind-blowing orgasm, but the main difference is that a Fleshlight sleeve is held in a case that looks like a flashlight, and most pocket pussies lack that same level of discretion.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Fleshlight is a type of stroker with a hard external case that resembles a flashlight, hiding a soft interior sleeve for penetration.
  • A pocket pussy is a generic term for any male masturbation stroker that has a vulva or vagina-like orifice, regardless of any structure similarities to a Fleshlight — and there are knock-off pocket pussies out there trying to pass off as the branded product.
  • Most pocket pussies are made using TPE blends (which are not considered safe) or silicone, while Fleshlights are made from the company’s proprietary Super Skin material.
  • Fleshlights feature adjustable tightness/suction but not all pocket pussies do, and both can be used for solo or partnered play as well as stamina training.
  • Fleshlights tend to be more durable compared to most pocket pussies (and often more intense, tight, and realistic).

Even if you don’t own one, you’ve probably heard of Fleshlight.

The reputable brand popularized sex toys for men and made using a toy (instead of your hand or a sock) more mainstream.

But they’re not the only ones making ingenious male masturbators that resemble a pussy, anus, or mouth.

In fact, there are plenty of budget-friendly pocket pussy alternatives out there, and whether they’re better than a Fleshlight is subjective.

Fleshlight Vs. Pocket Pussy: A Side-By-Side Comparison

split-screen image of a fleshlight on the left and a pocket pussy on the right with text that reads "vs" in the center

Although there are major similarities between Fleshlights and pocket pussies, there are also distinct things that set the two apart.

The information below offers a quick comparison between Fleshlights and various pocket pussies on the market.

Fleshlight Vs. Pocket Pussy
Price Range
Material
Orifice Type(s)
Color Options
Texture Options
Design
Realism
Functionality
Ease Of Cleaning
Overall Quality
Warranty
Accessories Available?
Durability
Fleshlight Vs. Pocket Pussy
Pocket Pussy
Price Range
$10 - $200+
Orifice Type(s)
Vagina, anus, mouth
Vagina, anus, mouth, non-orifice
Color Options
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Multiple ethnicities and colors
Texture Options
Many
Many
Design
Discreet with case
Discreet if case
Realism
Very realistic
Varies
Functionality
Manual or vibrating
Manual, vibrating, air technology, automatic
Ease Of Cleaning
Depends on model
Depends on model
Overall Quality
High
Low to High
Warranty
Only defective sleeves can be replaced
Varies
Accessories Available?
Yes
Yes
Durability
High
Low to high

 

While Fleshlight has a limited number of stroker styles, they offer plenty of variety, including orifices modeled after nearly 100 porn stars between their Fleshlight Girls and Fleshjack Boys lines, alone.

Pocket pussy design options are almost endless given that they’re a generic alternative manufactured by a wide range of sex toy companies.

High-quality pocket pussies often come with a price tag closer to Fleshlights.

However, there are also low to mid-quality options that provide a similar (albeit less customizable) experience at a lower price, which could be more suitable for beginners.

It’s worth noting too, that there are a lot of Fleshlight knock-offs out there, crafted from less-than-safe materials, so it’s important to do your research (and likely avoid shopping for them on Amazon.)

Advantages Of A Fleshlight

There are several reasons to choose a Fleshlight, which is one of the most well-known and reputable adult brands for a reason.

The benefits of a Fleshlight include:

Despite the lengthy list of pros, some find the Fleshlight to be bulky or heavy as opposed to more portable pocket pussies, while others dislike the flashlight design.

We’ve found that some models make a loud clicking sound during thrusting, like the Riley Reid Utopia (which is common for many others), which may be noisier than other manual strokers (although not always).

Additionally, Fleshlights require a lot of lube (which can only be a water-based lube) and there is a degree of maintenance when it comes to cleaning, including the use of the company’s renewal powder (cornstarch).

Fleshlight material is body-safe but porous, which means it’s prone to bacteria, unlike nonporous silicone.

The Fleshlight is pricier than other budget male masturbators on the market, although it isn’t necessarily always the most expensive option.

As great as it is, one company can’t satisfy all customers, and Fleshlight competes with dozens of other manufacturers who have equally positive reviews.

Advantages Of A Pocket Pussy

Pocket pussies are available from tons of different brands, offering a wider range of choices than the singular Fleshlight company can.

Here are some of the reasons to opt for an alternative masturbatory aid.

Benefits of a pocket pussy versus a Fleshlight include:

  • Greater range of brands and product features to choose from.
  • Smaller and larger versions are available that feel like real sex due to additional body parts like a pelvis, hips, or butt cheeks — as well as full-torso options that include breasts (yes, really!)
  • Ability to choose features like automation, automatic connectivity, or air suction technology for a variety of sensations.
  • Very realistic and life-like material (often TPE, which isn’t the safest) for a lower price tag.
  • Wider range of price points for similar quality, which can make them more accessible.
  • Some require less proprietary fuss when it comes to cleaning and maintenance, or what you can use to do either.
  • Some pocket pussies can be used with a range of lubes, not just water-based.
  • Discreet options are available, including styles with lockable tops or cases.

The major benefits of a pocket pussy over a Fleshlight relate to what you can use to clean and maintain your toy.

Fleshlights, being made of proprietary material, require not only surface treatment with Fleshlight Renewal Powder (which is 100% cornstarch), but they cannot be cleaned with general soaps or sex toy cleaners.

Only the company’s Fleshwash is compatible — so you’re cleaning your Fleshlight with that, or plain water, as soaps and detergents can degrade the sleeve material.

Most pocket pussies can be washed thoroughly with any type of sex toy cleaner or mild soap you have on hand.

Despite all their benefits, not all pocket pussies are as customizable as Fleshlights.

You’re also not guaranteed the same stellar customer support as Fleshlight provides, as other brands may not respond to feedback or questions.

While more affordable models are available, pocket pussies are not always as durable or long-lasting as Fleshlights, meaning that you’ll need to invest more money in replacements down the line.

The Difference Between Fleshlights And Pocket Pussies

Before we dive into the pocket pussy vs Fleshlight debate, it’s important to define what they are.

They have some similarities — like featuring a soft sleeve for penile penetration — but there are also clear design differences.

What Is A Fleshlight?

Collage Image Of Fleshlight Girls - Elsa Jean Masturbator With Inset Of Namesake Star

Fleshlights resemble a flashlight on the exterior, with a vagina, anus, or mouth as the opening to a textured interior held discreetly within its case, although not all Fleshlights resemble a human orifice.

This masturbatory aid for men popularized the use of other masturbation sleeves — aka strokers — in the sexual wellness industry and took jerking off to a whole new level.

Fleshlight sleeves often contain different stimulation patterns inside, including ridges, bumps, and nodes.

And according to the people who enjoy them, they feel pretty amazing.

What Is A Pocket Pussy?

Closeup Photograph Of Belladonna's Pocket Stroker And Its Packaging

A pocket pussy is basically any male stroker or masturbator that’s portable and has a vulva-like orifice.

Sometimes it will contain a hard exterior and a soft interior as Fleshlights do, but not always — some pocket pussies are not held in a case.

The most popular brands that manufacture pocket pussies include Tenga, Kiiroo, Pipedream, and Cal Exotics, although DIY versions count.

While these brands don’t have access to the exact Super Skin formula (no one but Fleshlight does), many have formulated their own versions using TPE (also known as “fake silicone”) for the most lifelike texture possible — even though it isn’t the safest sex toy material.

For example, Cal Exotics and Pipedream use a material called “FantaFlesh” while Doc Johnson uses “UR3 UltraSkyn.”

Beyond TPE, a common material for pocket pussies is silicone, a non-porous body-safe alternative that’s easier to clean and less prone to collecting bacteria — even when compared to Fleshlights.

Like the Fleshlight, the interior lining of pocket pussies may contain different patterns and textures to simulate real sex and add sensation, but only some feature adjustable tightness or suction.

A pocket pussy is often compact and lightweight, and for the most part, discreet.

However, some are larger than pocket-sized and emulate other real body parts like inner thighs, a pelvis, or butt cheeks — all of which tends to be the exact opposite of discreet.

Just like the Fleshlight, pocket pussies can be used for stamina training, partnered or solo play, and are often powered by your own thrusting motion unless you purchase an automatic version.

Deciding between a pocket pussy and a Fleshlight comes down to a few factors, including style (realistic or fantasy), price, and material.

How To Choose Between Fleshlight And A Pocket Pussy

photograph of product tester justin holding the riley reid utopia fleshlight while touching the surface of the material

Differences between pocket pussies and Fleshlights exist, no matter how similar they seem.

Both are used for the same purpose — solo and partnered pleasure — as well as stamina training (lasting longer during sex).

While Fleshlight offers an entire STU (stamina training unit) line dedicated to endurance training, you can find extra-tight budget-friendly pocket pussies with a little online shopping.

While some of the pros and cons even out, they all give you some insight into whether a Fleshlight or pocket pussy is better for you.

You might prefer a Fleshlight if you:

You might prefer a pocket pussy if you:

  • Have a small budget or want a sleeve with a lower price tag.
  • Want to choose from as many products or features as possible.
  • Don’t want an artificial vagina inside a flashlight aesthetic.
  • Seek the quietest toy possible.
  • Prefer something that’s low-maintenance to clean and can be used with a range of lubes and sex toy cleaners.
  • Want a ton of options from various manufacturers.

Fleshlights and other pocket pussy sleeves do have some things in common, but they also have a lot of differences that can be dealbreakers for buyers.

Figuring out your needs and desires will help you figure out which option is right for you.

What Feels Better: Fleshlight Or Pocket Pussy?

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all-penises answer to this question, as it depends on the product — and who you ask.

The Fleshlight provides a lot of cool features, collections, and textures to try out and plenty of men love the way they feel more than any other type of masturbator or stroker.

However, plenty of other sex toy companies have taken inspiration from the iconic brand — and have their own unique toys and a customer base that positively raves about them.

Our best advice?

Try a Fleshlight and a pocket pussy to see what you think about the experience.

Best Fleshlights To Try

If you’re looking for a new Fleshlight — whether buying one for the first time or replacing a beloved favorite — our top recommendations below are the perfect place to start.

photograph of fleshlight pink lady heavenlyClassic Pink Lady Heavenly

While Fleshlight offers a variety of product options, this classic pink vaginal sleeve has been around for years, remaining a consistent favorite among connoisseurs.

The “heavenly” texture inside is loved by plenty of Fleshlight fans, old and new, and it’s a great beginner option if you’ve never used one before.

photograph of a clear fleshlight quickshotFleshlight Quickshot

The Quickshot is the smallest Fleshlight model available, sized at just 3.5″ long.

It offers genital orifices (including some of the most popular porn stars) as well as non-anatomical styles if you prefer.

The Quickshot is open-ended on both sides and comes in both realistic and see-through sleeves.

product photograph of the fleshlight universal launchFleshlight Universal Launch & Quickshot Launch

For those looking for an automatic, hands-free experience with their Fleshlight, the Launch series works with full-sized models (Universal Launch) and Quickshots (Quickshot Launch).

Either one is perfect for automated stroking but you must use the model that fits your Fleshlight correctly — the Universal Launch won’t work with Quickshots, nor will full-sized Fleshlights work with the Quickshot Launch.

Fleshlight Girls: Riley Reid Utopia

The Riley Reid Fleshlight, designed after its namesake porn star, was loved by our testing team for its gorgeous vulva and exciting internal texture.

Utopia (Vulva)
Riley Reid Utopia
4.8
$79.99
Pros:
  • Feels Incredible & Surprisingly Realistic
  • Unique Interior Texture
  • Simple to Use, Adjustable Suction
  • Pretty Easy to Clean
Cons:
  • Noisier Than Expected
  • Cleaning Takes More Work Than Regular Masturbation
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: Featuring an unbelievably sexy vulva (signed by Riley Reid!), this is one of the most popular Fleshlight Girl models for a reason. Intuitive to use, the innovative skin-like sleeve texture is unique and totally blew our expectations for Fleshlights out of the water.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $79.99 @ Adam & Eve

Where To Buy A Pocket Pussy

If you’d rather purchase a pocket pussy instead of a Fleshlight, our most trusted vendors offer a variety to choose from, including:

Closing Thoughts

At the end of the day, Fleshlight is a brand, whereas a pocket pussy is a type of male masturbator or stroker that includes Fleshlight under its umbrella.

While both are equally popular, there’s a reason why people shell out the extra cash for a Fleshlight.

Opting for a more durable and reliable sex toy can save you money down the line, but if your main goal is versatility and more options, the wide range of pocket pussies on the internet is worth perusing as well.

Editor’s Note: This article is part of our Complete Guide To Fleshlights and Everything Fleshlight hub, in-depth and evolving resources that comprehensively explore and review all aspects of Fleshlights from the company’s discreet billing and shipping, to the types of products they carry, how to use them, materials, and safety.