4 Best Fleshlight Girls (Celebrity Pornstar Models)

It was hard choosing the best pornstar Fleshlights from the Girls’ line, but someone had to do it. We tested 12 models over 130 hours to find our top picks.
photograph of the four best fleshlight pornstar girls after our testing: autumn falls cream, riley reid utopia, mia malkova boss level, violet myers ahegao
We independently research and vet everything we recommend. Our team is supported by affiliate commissions. Learn more →
Updated:January 2024

Our Top Recommend Fleshlight Girls:

Best Overall
Also Good
Tightest Fit
Most Exciting
$79.95
$79.99
$79.95
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Autumn Falls Cream combines the best of everything the Fleshlight Girls series has to offer with a gorgeous model, tight squeeze, and one of their most exciting textures. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: One of the most popular models of pornstar Fleshlights, Riley Reid’s Utopia lives up to the name with a fit and feel that will have anyone seeing stars after they’ve tried it themselves. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: The Mia Malkova “Boss Level” Fleshlight is an anal model that boasts an insanely tight grip and supremely stimulating interior texture when you’re looking for the snuggest fit possible. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: Filled to the brim with a varied and intense collection of lock-like, offset chambers, Violet Myers' Ahegao has the most exciting Fleshlight textures our team has ever experienced. [Full Review + Video]

Best Overall
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Autumn Falls Cream combines the best of everything the Fleshlight Girls series has to offer with a gorgeous model, tight squeeze, and one of their most exciting textures. [Full Review + Video]

Also Good
$79.99
Description:

Bottom Line: One of the most popular models of pornstar Fleshlights, Riley Reid’s Utopia lives up to the name with a fit and feel that will have anyone seeing stars after they’ve tried it themselves. [Full Review + Video]

Tightest Fit
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: The Mia Malkova “Boss Level” Fleshlight is an anal model that boasts an insanely tight grip and supremely stimulating interior texture when you’re looking for the snuggest fit possible. [Full Review + Video]

Most Exciting
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Filled to the brim with a varied and intense collection of lock-like, offset chambers, Violet Myers' Ahegao has the most exciting Fleshlight textures our team has ever experienced. [Full Review + Video]

Fleshlight offers more than 60 pocket pussies and male masturbators inspired by some of the world’s hottest female adult film stars — and each one offers an appearance and texture that’s entirely unique to the model.

Finding the best Fleshlight Girl was a hard job — but somebody had to do it.

(And we did!)

Fun Fact:

  • According to data provided exclusively to us by Fleshlight, Violet Myers was the best-selling pornstar Fleshlight Girl of 2023!

After more than 130 hours of cumulative research and testing, we’ve concluded that Autumn Falls Cream and Riley Reid Utopia are the best Fleshlight Girls models available.

We’ll share our other top picks — including the tightest anal model, which ones didn’t make our list (and why), along with what makes a great Fleshlight Girl.

Our Research, Testing & Review Methodology:

  • Fleshlight Girl Requirements: Quality construction and materials, realistic appearance, pleasurable texture, comfortable fit, excellent performance, ease of cleaning, and user-friendly design.
  • Fleshlight Girls Considered: 65
  • Models Tested: 12
  • Tested By: Justin Perlman, David Talquenca, John Brownstone, David Rella
  • Total Research Time: 130+ hours across 3 months (as of 09/21/2023)

Best Overall: Autumn Falls Cream (Vulva)

Best Overall
Autumn Falls Cream
4.9
$79.95
Pros:
  • Unique And Intense Waffle Texture
  • Multiple Varied Chambers Within Sleeve
  • Excellent Tightness, Comfortable Fit
  • Beautiful Pussy And Accurate Skin Tone
  • Simple To Use, Adjustable Suction
Cons:
  • May Be Too Tight For Bigger Penises
  • Requires More Care When Cleaning
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: From a beautiful actress to a gorgeous Fleshlight, the Autumn Falls Cream texture puts pleasure in the palm of your hand, offering a tight fit and a wild interior that will keep you on your toes as you go deeper. The texture within the sleeve changes throughout and includes a waffle-like lattice that does amazing things to your dick — trust us on that one.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $71.96 @ Fleshlight –> CODE: WHI10

For our list of the best Fleshlight Girls, Autumn Falls’ Cream takes the top spot, and at least for me, it all started with just a glance at the box.

The cover of every Fleshlight Girl package features a photograph of an undeniably beautiful woman, but Falls blows some of them out of the water.

photograph of justin holding the autumn falls cream fleshlight box in his hand while making a startled yet excited expression on his face

One look at her and my first question was why this lady isn’t a mainstream movie star.

Maybe it’s a matter of personal taste, but having a great photo on the box went a long way toward making this Fleshlight girl sleeve a testing priority.

Speaking of beauty, the reproduction of Autumn’s vagina is as entrancing as the rest of her.

“It does have a wide set of labia lips,” Fleshlight Girl tester David Talquenca pointed out.

photograph of tester david holding the autumn falls cream vulva fleshlight and pointing to its orifice

“One of the things that I loved about this Fleshlight is that it comes in an ebony color,” he continued.

The detailed, flowering labia lips pull you in metaphorically before pulling you in literally.

Seriously, I have had to fight the urge to go down on this Fleshlight, as I talked about in my review of the Autumn Falls Fleshlight.

(You can do that, but it doesn’t taste as good as the real thing.)

We all know it’s what’s inside that counts, so let’s talk about the texture.

Some of the Fleshlight pornstar variants have a monotonous or consistent pattern of bumps and nodules throughout, or a consistent level of tightness.

Autumn Falls’ Cream texture goes all out when it comes to variation.

Inside this Fleshlight girl sleeve, several different chambers flow seamlessly into each other, taking your dick on a wild ride as you pump and stroke.

close-up image of the autumn falls cream texture diagram on the box with text overlay that reads: a nubby texture is the first thing you'll feel when using the autumn falls cream fleshlight

The chamber closest to the opening welcomes you with angled walls that tightly grip and slide along your head and shaft as you enter an even tighter section filled with soft nodules.

“It does have a pretty tight grip inside,” tester David Talquenca noted.

The next gateway has angled fins along with another tight space covered in raised ridges, giving way to a chamber that looks like a waffle on the side of the box.

photograph of justin pointing to the waffle texture on the diagram of autumn falls cream fleshlight's box

This intricate set of textures means you need to be a bit more thorough when cleaning the sleeve after use, but it is still a relatively quick and easy process.

Combine this insane setup of mindblowing textures and the suction created through a closed end cap, and you have a powerhouse of a pornstar Fleshlight.

Also Good: Riley Reid Utopia (Vulva)

Also Good
Riley Reid Utopia
4.8
$79.99
Pros:
  • Feels Incredible & Surprisingly Realistic
  • Unique Interior Texture
  • Simple to Use, Adjustable Suction
  • Pretty Easy to Clean
Cons:
  • Noisier Than Expected
  • Cleaning Takes More Work Than Regular Masturbation
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: Featuring an unbelievably sexy vulva (signed by Riley Reid!), this is one of the most popular Fleshlight Girl models for a reason. Intuitive to use, the innovative skin-like sleeve texture is unique and totally blew our expectations for Fleshlights out of the water.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $79.99 @ Adam & Eve

We did a much longer review of the Riley Reid Utopia if you’d like to learn everything there is to know about her, but we’ll give you the gist below.

This was my first Fleshlight ever, and even after trying dozens of other models since, she still stands as one of the best Fleshlight Girls.

photograph of product tester justin wearing a sly grin after unboxing the riley reid utopia fleshlight

Right from the box, I knew I was in for something special.

Even though I wasn’t familiar with Reid’s work in the beginning, her photo stood out with her charming smile.

Fleshlight Girl tester, David Talquenca, agreed that she’s an especially “cute model.”

The actual sleeve is just as inviting and beautiful as Reid herself, featuring a pussy that just screams “star power.”

photograph of product tester justin holding the riley reid utopia fleshlight to show its opening, demonstrating how easy it is to use

The fit and feel of the Riley Reid Utopia are stellar.

I’ll admit that it is not as tight as some other vaginal models, but there is no sacrifice when it comes to the texture you’ll discover.

Filled with finger-like nubs, the real show stopper is the chamber door near the middle of the internal sleeve.

diagram of the riley reid utopia fleshlight sleeve texture featuring coiled bumps and ridges

The pathway has these thick “claws” that not only tighten the space but massage your shaft as you move in and out.

The bonus?

The simple (yet very effective) interior of this Fleshlight girl sleeve requires minimal cleaning.

Just a good rinse, dry, and powder is all you need to keep it in tip-top shape and lasting as long as possible.

The Riley Reid Utopia is a great all-around pick for a pornstar pocket pussy, especially if it’s your very first.

Tightest Fit: Mia Malkova “Boss Level” (Anal)

Tightest Fit
Mia Malkova Boss Level
4.8
$79.95
Pros:
  • Fantastic Tightness
  • Unique Curved Interior
  • Intense Suction And Stimulation
  • Extra Cushion For The Pushin’
  • Simple To Use, Adjustable Suction
Cons:
  • Monotonous Texture
  • Might Be Too Tight For Thicker Penises
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: Mia Malkova has generously offered her all-star ass for this anal Fleshlight and it truly is a Boss Level experience. Featuring a tight internal sleeve and a bouncy, soft orifice that really does add some cushion for your pushin’, this is perfect for anal aficionados and our team loved it.
$67.05 @ The Enhanced Male –> CODE: WHI10 $71.96 @ Fleshlight –> CODE: WHI10

It should be no surprise that an anal model wins for the tightest Fleshlight Girl, but there is more going on here than just a good grip, as I pointed out in my review of the Mia Malkova pornstar Fleshlight.

As with other Fleshlight Girls, the photo on the box just pulls you in with Mia Malkova’s absolutely jaw-dropping ass front and center.

photograph of justin making an "ooooh" expression while looking at the mia malkova boss level fleshlight girl box

“She’s an attractive model with a nice butt,” Fleshlight Girl tester David Talquenca said.

John Brownstone added that it was “nice to see a lady with some curves for a change” when it came time to test Mia Malkova.

The sleeve itself is no less alluring, with a shockingly accurate reproduction of Mia’s anus.

“For a synthetic butthole, it’s a nice one,” John noted.

Unlike the vaginal models, the anal sleeves offer a bit more cushioning for a softer and more comfortable impact.

Considering Malkova’s ample cheeks, the extra padding feels appropriate and exciting.

photograph of justin holding the mia malkova boss level fleshlight to display its padded orifice with text overlay that reads: the mia malkova boss level anal fleshlight offers plenty of cushion for the pushin'

Once inside, the texture of this Fleshlight girl sleeve doesn’t have the same setup as other vaginal models.

Instead of a straight line with multiple chambers, this offers a river-like channel that curves as you go deeper inside.

David said he loved the “tight feel” of the internal sleeve, despite its lack of variation in texture.

There is a consistent wall of finger-like bumps that hug your penis tightly while tickling your shaft as you go to town, but there isn’t a lot of variety throughout — and no surprise chambers.

photograph of tester justin holding the boxes for the mia malkova boss level and autumn falls cream fleshlights to compare their texture maps, with text overlay that explains the mia malkova features a narrow river-like channel throughout the sleeve

The Mia Malkova Boss Level texture may be more monotonous compared to others, but you won’t be hurting for stimulation.

The one-two punch of the tightness and suction on this pornstar Fleshlight sleeve will have your knees wobbling and shaking harder than Mia’s ass itself.

That being said, if you are rocking an absolute monster of a cock, this might be too tight a fit for you.

Removing the sleeve from the case will allow for some extra expansion and control so you can enjoy this tight anal Fleshlight much more comfortably.

Most Exciting Texture: Violet Myers “Ahegao” (Anal)

Most Exciting Texture
Violet Myers Ahegao
4.9
$79.95
Pros:
  • 100% Orgasm Rate During Our Testing
  • Incredible Tightness & Stellar Suction
  • Four Textured Chambers, Exciting Twists
  • Satisfying Squeeze & Grip
  • Plenty Of Cushion For The Pushin’
Cons:
  • May Bring You To Orgasm TOO Quickly
  • Might Be Too Tight For Larger Penises
  • Air Drying Can Take Hours
  • Risk Of Mold Growth If Not Maintained Properly
Bottom Line: The Violet Myers Fleshlight with Ahegao texture is an anal model that’s as much of a knockout as the star herself. Offering tightness and suction that’s too legit to quit, it never once failed to deliver a satisfying orgasm. (Sometimes a little too quickly...but we aren’t complaining!)
$71.96 @ Fleshlight –> CODE: WHI10

This one absolutely blew my mind, as I pointed out in my review of the Violet Myers pornstar Fleshlight — and it ended up knocking out our former top pick for this category, Emily Willis.

Normally, my initial excitement over trying a new Fleshlight Girl is based on the photo of the pornstar on the box, but I was still taken aback when I saw this one.

photograph of product tester justin holding the violet myers ahegao anal fleshlight in his hand while using his other hand to gesture toward it as though an invitation to the viewer to try it after reading his review of the anal pornstar fleshlight

Violet Myers is totally my type, as I tend to prefer women with some curves — I was captivated by her image, even though I’d never actually heard of her until her Fleshlight landed on my doorstep.

Then I turned the box on its side and saw the texture.

Filled with a set of chambers that almost resemble an intricate key lock, the offset ridges make the inside look a little like a meat grinder — but one that you can’t wait to put your dick in.

(Again and again, in my case.)

photograph of product tester justin holding the violet myers ahegao anal fleshlight box in his hand while pointing to the key lock-like texture on the back of the box to display what it looks like to the viewer

The offset texture design mixed with the suction — which pulls the walls of the sleeve inward to add some tightness — ensures you will feel every little detail during each stroke the realistic butthole is tight — but not uncomfortably so.

To be honest, I had to test this one a few times before I was even able to write notes for my review — because the Ahegao finished me so quickly each time.

Initially, I was concerned that all of the internal ridges would make this thing a nightmare to clean.

It did take a bit more care to make sure everything was rinsed out, but it really didn’t take much more effort than any other Fleshlight.

I went into this Fleshlight Girl not knowing a thing about her — and she quickly earned a permanent spot in my Fleshlight rotation (and spank bank).

How We Made Our Picks & Features We Considered

photograph of justin holding the emily willis squirt fleshlight with the vulva facing the viewer

Our team initially considered and closely examined all 65 Fleshlight Girls models (as of this writing), narrowing our list down to 12 for personal testing.

Although we considered the popularity of each pornstar and its fan base, we also explored the varied textures throughout the entire line, selecting both vulva and anal models for testing.

The most important criteria to look for in a Fleshlight Girl include:

When choosing the best Fleshlight Girls, we weighed and tested:

  • The appearance and external design
  • The sensations it provides
  • The fit and feel of the sleeve
  • The texture and how noticeable it is (or isn’t)
  • Ease of use
  • Ease of clean up — especially among those with intricate textures
  • Whether we would use it again on our own, outside of an official testing capacity

Fleshlight Girls That Didn’t Make The Cut

With some rare exceptions, all of the Fleshlight Girls models deserve at least an Honorable Mention.

They all feel great and get the job done in their own way, it just comes down to your personal preferences and needs.

Here are some of the other Fleshlight Girls we tested that didn’t get high enough marks to be included among the best pornstar Fleshlights, although they were enjoyed by our testing team nonetheless:

  • Emily Willis “Squirt”: This Fleshlight was previously voted the most exciting texture — until Violet Myers Ahegao dethroned her. (Sorry, Emily.)
  • Elsa Jean “Tasty”: This one was so close to cracking the top. It has a great fit and interesting texture, but it was almost too much.
  • Angela White “Indulge”: Despite White fitting more of my personal tastes in women and body types, the texture just didn’t bring it as much as some others we tried.
  • Abella Danger “Danger”: There isn’t anything bad about this one, it just didn’t make a huge impression on our testing team.
  • Dillion Harper “Crush”: As cute and crushable as Harper is, this one felt almost ironically named. It lacked a sense of tightness and had a lackluster texture.
  • Eva Lovia “Sugar”: Like Abella Danger, this was all-around good but not great. The fit and feel are perfectly serviceable, but it’s not the first one I reach for.
  • Kenzie Reeves “Cream Puff”: While this one did have impressive tightness and a detailed texture, it lost some points on cleaning. The inside is detailed enough that it took more time to truly clean out than others.

What To Know About Fleshlight Girls

photograph of the mia malkova boss level fleshlight box on a table beside its signature fleshlight

We have a whole hub devoted to the wonderful world of Fleshlights, but here are some quickfire answers to some of the biggest questions you might have about the Girls’ line.

What Are Fleshlight Girls?

Fleshlights are tubular sex toys for people with penises, and the Fleshlight Girls series is specifically designed around the anatomy of popular adult film and porn stars.

The material is a proprietary blend called SuperSkin and the interior of the sleeve is textured for maximum pleasure.

Each Fleshlight Girl model features its own unique internal texture — like snowflakes, no two are exactly alike.

Additionally, every Fleshlight Girl resembles the vulva or anal orifice of its namesake star, with hyper-realistic detailing and an as-accurate-as-possible skin tone.

The tightest Fleshlight girl models tend to be those of the anal variety, although you’ll find plenty of tightness among the entire range of vaginal strokers, as well.

Who Should Use Fleshlight Girls?

Fleshlights are for people with penises and if you’re a huge fan of the pornstars the company has done collabs with, then these are for you.

You might enjoy a Fleshlight Girl if you:

  • Want an extensive range of textures and visual aesthetics that include a human-like vulva or anal orifice that closely resembles your favorite star(s) working in the adult industry.
  • Seek the most realistic simulation of vaginal or anal sex when a partner isn’t available.
  • Prefer using a pocket pussy, stroker, or masturbator with a hard external case that promotes cleanliness and discretion.
  • Want a pocket pussy or stroker that offers fully adjustable suction during use.
  • Are interested in exploring fantasies that revolve around your favorite porn stars — especially while watching their performances during use.
  • Prefer a manual stroker that has an option for automation through an accessory (Fleshlight Universal Launch).
  • Aren’t seeking something to improve your endurance (such as a Stamina Training Unit).
  • Don’t mind the cleaning and maintenance required of Fleshlights.

Pros And Cons Of Fleshlight Girls

Everything in life — even these masturbatory masterpieces — has some plusses and minuses to consider.

Fleshlight Girl Pros:

  • They feel amazing during use and each offers its own unique texture to explore — I think of them as an adventure for your dick.
  • They’re great for an immersive experience, especially when paired with a VR headset or while watching point-of-view (POV) porn videos.
  • Being crafted by a trusted brand, Fleshlights are well-built from quality materials.
  • The Fleshlight Girls line offers plenty of variety so there’s something to suit every preference, whether you’re into vaginal or anal sex — or both.
  • With proper care and maintenance, they can last a very long time.

Fleshlight Girl Cons:

  • More effort is needed to clean a Fleshlight compared to just using your hand.
  • They’re not necessarily as discreet as you might think — and some make squishy popping sounds during use (yes, really).
  • Getting lazy with cleaning and drying can lead to mold and bacteria buildup so you’ve got to be on your game when it comes to maintenance.
  • Currently, there are no mouth orifices available in the series so if that’s what you’re after, you’re out of luck and limited to the standard Boost series.

Are Fleshlight Girls Safe?

Overall, Fleshlights are very safe and the Girls’ line is no exception, but there are some things you should know ahead of time.

Here are some safety considerations you should know about Fleshlight Girls:

  • Materials: The SuperSkin material is safe, but since we don’t 100% know what is actually in it aside from a mineral oil polymer, those with sensitive skin or known allergies should do some research before using any Fleshlight Girl. It is also porous and cannot be sanitized during cleaning.
  • Cleaning: Proper Fleshlight cleaning and drying is paramount if you want to keep your toy in good condition. Forgetting to clean and dry your Fleshlight can lead to mold and bacteria growth inside, which is a health risk and can ruin your toy.
  • Using lube: For the best experience with your Fleshlight Girl, make sure you always use a personal lubricant with Fleshlight and stick to water-based lubes only. The SuperSkin doesn’t play well with silicone-based or oil-based lubes and using those can degrade the material.
  • Using condoms: You do not need to use a condom with a Fleshlight Girl but you can — especially if you find it makes clean-up easier. If you choose to wrap it up beforehand, use non-lubricated condoms or those that use water-based lubricant.

Closing Thoughts

It was so hard to choose the best pornstar Fleshlights from the Girls’ line, but someone had to do it.

Best Overall
Also Good
Tightest Fit
Most Exciting
$79.95
$79.99
$79.95
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Autumn Falls Cream combines the best of everything the Fleshlight Girls series has to offer with a gorgeous model, tight squeeze, and one of their most exciting textures. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: One of the most popular models of pornstar Fleshlights, Riley Reid’s Utopia lives up to the name with a fit and feel that will have anyone seeing stars after they’ve tried it themselves. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: The Mia Malkova “Boss Level” Fleshlight is an anal model that boasts an insanely tight grip and supremely stimulating interior texture when you’re looking for the snuggest fit possible. [Full Review + Video]

Description:

Bottom Line: Filled to the brim with a varied and intense collection of lock-like, offset chambers, Violet Myers' Ahegao has the most exciting Fleshlight textures our team has ever experienced. [Full Review + Video]

Best Overall
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Autumn Falls Cream combines the best of everything the Fleshlight Girls series has to offer with a gorgeous model, tight squeeze, and one of their most exciting textures. [Full Review + Video]

Also Good
$79.99
Description:

Bottom Line: One of the most popular models of pornstar Fleshlights, Riley Reid’s Utopia lives up to the name with a fit and feel that will have anyone seeing stars after they’ve tried it themselves. [Full Review + Video]

Tightest Fit
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: The Mia Malkova “Boss Level” Fleshlight is an anal model that boasts an insanely tight grip and supremely stimulating interior texture when you’re looking for the snuggest fit possible. [Full Review + Video]

Most Exciting
$79.95
Description:

Bottom Line: Filled to the brim with a varied and intense collection of lock-like, offset chambers, Violet Myers' Ahegao has the most exciting Fleshlight textures our team has ever experienced. [Full Review + Video]

At the end of the day, they’re all winners — even if they couldn’t make it into our list of top recommendations.

Each Fleshlight Girl has something wonderful to offer, whether it’s tantalizing texture, gorilla grip tightness, or just the prettiest lips you’ve ever seen.

Keep in mind what was great or not-so-great for our testers is based on personal experience, so feel free to try them all to find your own favorites!

Editor’s Note: This article is part of our Complete Guide To Fleshlights and Everything Fleshlight hub, in-depth and evolving resources that comprehensively explore and review all aspects of Fleshlights from the company’s discreet billing and shipping, to the types of products they carry, how to use them, materials, and safety.